Fanie Scholtz
20 May 2025

The Training ROI Myth: Why You Can’t Afford to Skip Measurement

In boardrooms and budget meetings across South Africa and the Middle East, training is often approved with optimism—but evaluated with vagueness.

“It was well received.”
“The facilitator was great.”
“People seemed engaged.”
“We got really good feedback.”

But here’s the hard truth:

If you’re not measuring training ROI, you’re not managing it.
And if you’re not managing it, you’re not getting it.

At SydSen Training, we work with forward-thinking businesses to design and deliver programmes that don’t just feel good—they perform. And we’ve learned that most training doesn’t fail because it’s irrelevant or uninspiring—it fails because it’s invisible. There’s no system in place to track what’s working, what’s changing, or what’s wasting time and money.

This article unpacks the myth of unmeasurable training, the real cost of skipping evaluation, and how to build a learning model where ROI isn’t an afterthought—it’s a design principle.


The Myth: “You Can’t Measure Training ROI”

This myth comes in a few flavours:

  • “Soft skills are hard to quantify.”

  • “We can’t track long-term behavioural change.”

  • “Training impact depends on the individual, so it’s subjective.”

  • “We don’t have time to do follow-ups.”

These sound reasonable. But they all lead to the same result:
Training that’s funded, attended, and then forgotten.

But the truth is, you absolutely can measure training ROI—
You just need to know what to look for, and how to look for it.


What You’re Losing Without Measurement

When training isn’t measured:

  • You keep funding programmes with no evidence of impact.

  • You repeat sessions that feel good but change nothing.

  • You can’t defend L&D spend when budgets tighten.

  • You lose credibility with leadership and operational teams.

  • You miss opportunities to scale or embed what works.

Most dangerously—you assume learning is happening, when it might not be.


What Does Real ROI Look Like?

Let’s define ROI as more than just rands and cents. At SydSen, we measure across four tiers:


1. Reaction (Did they like it?)

The classic “smile sheet.” Important, but superficial.

✅ Helpful for: benchmarking facilitator performance, session design, and engagement.
🚫 Not helpful for: proving business value.


2. Learning (Did they learn it?)

Measured through:

  • Pre/post assessments

  • Scenario-based quizzes

  • Knowledge checks during the session

✅ Helpful for: proving knowledge transfer.
🚫 Not enough to prove practical application.


3. Behaviour (Did they apply it?)

The most ignored—but most critical layer.

Measured by:

  • Manager feedback and observation

  • Self-reports and peer assessments

  • Behavioural pulse checks 30–60–90 days post-session

✅ Helpful for: identifying which parts of training are “sticking.”


4. Results (Did it affect the business?)

This is the ROI conversation that matters.

Measured by:

  • Performance KPIs (sales uplift, error reduction, service scores)

  • Retention or engagement shifts

  • Productivity or quality improvements

  • Customer feedback trends

The key is not to measure everything—but to measure what matters.
Each programme should have one or two business-aligned metrics baked into its design.


What’s Getting in the Way?

Training is treated as an “event,” not a process

Once the session ends, so does the attention.

L&D teams work in isolation

Without alignment to business strategy or operations, it’s hard to define relevant metrics.

Managers aren’t involved

They don’t reinforce, observe, or report on application—so data is lost.

Tech is underutilised

Many businesses have LMS platforms or internal tools—but don’t use them to collect feedback, pulse check behaviour, or automate tracking.


The SydSen Solution: ROI by Design

We don’t measure at the end—we design for ROI from the beginning.

1. Start With a Measurable Outcome

We ask:

  • What business problem are you trying to solve?

  • What will look different if this works?

  • Who can help validate that change?

Then we build learning objectives that point to that outcome.


2. Layer Your Measurement Model

We help clients design a simple but powerful measurement stack:

  • Quick digital reaction surveys

  • Auto-graded knowledge assessments

  • Follow-up behaviour check-ins (email/WhatsApp/LMS)

  • Manager scorecards

These can be automated and built into your existing platforms.


3. Report the Right Metrics to the Right People

  • Executives want business KPIs.

  • HR wants engagement and retention signals.

  • Managers want performance change.

  • Trainers want content relevance feedback.

We deliver dashboards and summaries tailored to each level.


4. Turn Insights Into Action

Data without change is wasted.

We support:

  • Revisions to modules based on behavioural lag

  • Targeted coaching where knowledge isn’t translating

  • Reprioritisation of programmes based on ROI levels

The result? A living training system that evolves and improves—just like your people.


Case Study: ROI in Action

Client: National service provider in the Middle East
Training: Customer service and conflict resolution for 150 frontline staff
Previous model: One-off workshops with no follow-up
SydSen approach:

  • Pre/post assessments

  • Manager observation checklists

  • Post-programme NPS and complaint trend tracking

Outcome after 90 days:

  • Complaint escalation rate down 34%

  • Call resolution scores up 22%

  • Manager feedback indicated 4.7/5 improvement in behaviour

Leadership now sees L&D as a performance partner—not a cost centre.


ROI Doesn’t Happen by Accident

You wouldn’t run a marketing campaign with no analytics.
You wouldn’t invest in a sales tool with no revenue target.
So why invest in training with no plan to measure its return?

The myth that training ROI is hard to measure is just that—a myth.
The cost of believing it? Wasted time. Wasted budget. Wasted potential.


Final Thought: If You Can’t Measure It, You Can’t Defend It

In a world where talent is your biggest asset and skills evolve faster than ever, training is no longer optional—it’s infrastructure. But infrastructure requires metrics. Proof. Progress.

You don’t need to measure everything.
You just need to measure what matters, and act on what you find.

About the Author
Fanie Scholtz
Fanie Scholtz is the General Manager for Training & Development at SydSen Training Academy. With more than 22 years in automotive sales, marketing, and training, Fanie brings operational expertise and a passion for people development to his role. He leads customised learning programmes across Africa and the Middle East, helping dealerships and corporates upskill for performance and agility.
Ready to start transforming your business today?
Book a tailored demo with our experts and explore how SydSen Group’s integrated solutions can unlock growth, streamline performance, and future-proof your business—no matter your industry or scale. Let’s turn potential into measurable impact.
Join 500+ businesses already growing with Sydsen Group
Book a demo
Experience the power of our solutions firsthand. Schedule a personalised demo with our experts and discover how we can help you achieve your business goals.